Talk with the team ›
Piercing

Piercing Infection or Irritation? How to Tell the Difference

Most troubled piercings are irritated, not infected. Here is how to tell infection, irritation and rejection apart, what to do about each, and when to see a doctor straight away.

5 min read

Gloved hands working at a man's ear lobe during an ear piercing.

Many piercings that look angry are irritated rather than infected. Irritation shows up as redness, swelling, a small bump or a clear-to-whitish crust, and it usually has a cause you can remove: friction, the wrong products, or over-cleaning. An infection gets worse instead of better, with spreading redness, heat, increasing pain and thick, smelly green, yellow or grey discharge. If you think a piercing is infected, see a doctor and keep the jewellery in.

This guide is general information, not medical advice. It follows the guidance of the Association of Professional Piercers.

Is my piercing infected or just irritated?

The Association of Professional Piercers notes that irritation and allergy are far more common than infection, and that the wrong aftercare is the most common cause of a troubled piercing. Here's how the three usually look.

Normal healing

  • Some swelling, tenderness or bruising in the first days.
  • Itching.
  • A whitish-yellow fluid that dries into crust on the jewellery.

All of that is part of a piercing healing, and it settles over time.

Irritation

  • Redness or swelling that comes back after it had calmed down.
  • A small bump next to the piercing.
  • Soreness after the piercing was knocked, slept on or snagged.

Irritation usually has a trigger, and it improves once the trigger is gone.

Infection

  • Redness, swelling or pain that keeps increasing after the first few days.
  • Heat around the piercing.
  • A lot of thick green, yellow or grey discharge that smells bad.
  • Red streaks spreading from the piercing.
  • Fever, chills, nausea or dizziness.

Any of these means see a doctor straight away. Don't wait for it to sort itself out.

Close-up of an ear with three thin hoop piercings.

What about rejection?

Rejection is different again. The body slowly pushes the jewellery towards the surface. Signs include the jewellery looking closer to the skin than before, more of the bar showing, the skin over it looking thin or see-through, and the hole looking bigger. Surface and navel piercings are more prone to it than most. If you notice it, see your piercer early: there are options before it becomes a scar.

What causes piercing irritation?

The usual suspects, in roughly the order we see them:

  • Movement. Twisting, turning or playing with the jewellery. The old advice to move it so it doesn't stick is a myth.
  • Friction and pressure. Sleeping on it, a helmet pulled over a fresh ear, tight clothing over a navel, a phone pressed against the cartilage.
  • Strong products. Alcohol, hydrogen peroxide, tea-tree oil and ointments all irritate a fresh piercing.
  • Over-cleaning. Twice a day with sterile saline is enough.
  • The wrong jewellery. Metal with too much nickel can cause a reaction, so ask your piercer what your jewellery is made of. More on that in our guide to titanium versus surgical steel.
  • A bar that's too long. Once the swelling goes down, a long first bar can catch and move. A piercer can change it to a shorter one.

Not sure which one you're dealing with? Send us a clear photo in daylight on WhatsApp. We can't diagnose from a photo, and anything that looks like infection is a question for a doctor.

WhatsApp Canggu (Pererenan)

What to do if your piercing is irritated

  • Go back to basics. Wash your hands, use sterile saline labelled 0.9% sodium chloride twice a day, pat dry with paper towel, then leave it alone.
  • Remove the trigger. Sleep on the other side, keep hair, hats and helmets off it, and stop touching it.
  • Stop any extra products. No creams, oils or home-made salt mixes.
  • Have a piercer check the jewellery. Length and material matter.

Irritation often improves once the cause is removed. If it doesn't, or if it gets worse, see a doctor.

Back view of a person with a buzz cut, hoop ear piercings and a small tattoo.

Should I take my jewellery out if it's infected?

No. Keep the jewellery in until a piercer or a doctor has seen it. The Association of Professional Piercers warns that removing jewellery in the presence of an infection can lead to an abscess, because the surface closes and traps the infection inside.

Bali makes piercings work harder

On a Bali trip, a fresh piercing meets the ocean, villa pools, sunscreen, sweat and scooter helmets every day. They all add irritation, and water you can't control can carry bacteria, which is why a fresh piercing stays out of the sea and pools until it has healed. Keep a fresh piercing out of the sea and pools until it has healed, keep sunscreen away from it, and rinse in the shower after the beach. Our guide on swimming with a new piercing covers the water rules, and the full routine is in our piercing healing guide.

Studio room with black treatment beds, a sofa and a large window.

Talking to a piercer at our studios

If something looks off, you're welcome to message us or come in and talk to a piercer. The full menu of placements is on our piercing page.

Quick answers

How do I know if my piercing is infected? Infection gets worse instead of better: increasing redness, swelling, heat and pain, thick green, yellow or grey discharge that smells bad, red streaks or a fever. See a doctor straight away if you notice any of these.

Is yellow crust on my piercing a sign of infection? Usually not. A whitish-yellow fluid that dries into crust is normal while a piercing heals. A lot of thick, smelly discharge is different and needs a doctor.

Should I remove an infected piercing? No. Keep the jewellery in and see a doctor or a piercer. Removing it during an infection can lead to an abscess.

What is the bump next to my piercing? Most bumps are irritation, from movement, pressure, the wrong products or a bar that's too long. Remove the cause, keep to the saline routine and have a piercer check the jewellery.

Can I use tea-tree oil on an irritated piercing? No. Strong products like tea-tree oil, alcohol and hydrogen peroxide irritate a healing piercing. Stick to sterile saline.

Worried about your piercing?

Send us a photo, the date you were pierced and the placement on WhatsApp. For anything that looks like infection, see a doctor first.

WhatsApp Canggu (Pererenan)

WhatsApp Uluwatu (Bingin)

WhatsApp Seminyak (Kayu Aya)

You can also walk in at our Canggu studio in Pererenan, or find the studio nearest to you in Uluwatu or Seminyak. Canggu and Uluwatu are open daily from 9:00 to 21:00, Seminyak from 9:00 until midnight.

Sources: the Association of Professional Piercers aftercare guidance and troubleshooting guide.

By appointment

Questions we have not written up yet?

Ask us directly. We would rather answer before you book than after.